|
Liberal view (valuing individuals, liberty and enterprise)
|
Illiberal view (valuing the state, society, and social ‘norms’
more than the individual)
|
Evidence
|
|
Having
a large population is an opportunity for India (each individual is a valued
member)
|
Having a
large population is a problem for India (individuals who are poor
or illiterate illiterate are not valued)
|
The
size of the population has absolutely no relationship with a
country’s quality of life and wealth
|
|
A
person without education is fit to vote and form a judgement regarding
policy and people.
|
A
person without education is not fit to vote.
|
India's democracy has largely been
sustained by the uneducated voter.
|
|
The
government should not be allowed to interfere in matters when it is not absolutely
necessary.
|
The
government should control how many children one can have, whether one can
consume alcohol, and whether one can set up an industry.
|
It is
better to have a few laws that are enforced properly than thousands set up
on the whims and fancies of ‘do-gooders’.
|
|
It is
in the understanding of human incentives and implementing agencies that
good policy is based on. Good policy always succeeds in implementation.
|
Our
problems are to do with bad implementation of policies rather than policies
being bad in the first place.
|
A vast
literature spanning many centuries warns us on the fallibility of human
nature. Checks and balances are crucial to good policy design.
|
|
If
trains run in time but freedom of expression and liberty is lost, all is
lost.
|
The
Emergency was good for India.
|
Absolute
power corrupts absolutely. The atrocities of the Emergency were cast away
like poison by the people.
|
|
Human
beings are opportunistic but also innately ethical. When power is given to governments
without checks on its misuse, corruption becomes rampant.
|
Corruption
is caused by people being bad
|
Socialistic
and fascist societies invariably rank very high on the corruption scale.
|
|
It is
obligatory on the government to prevent mob violence, irrespective of its cause
|
BJP was
right in supporting the demolition of the Babri Masjid/ Congress supporters
were right in causing mob violence after Indira Gandhi’s
assassination.
|
This
was a cynical move to polarise the society and expand vote banks.
|
|
The
government has absolutely no business in doing business.
|
Nehru was
right in demanding that the public sector enter into things like production
of steel or running airlines. Do you believe that India Gandhi was right in
nationalising the banks.
|
Existing
enterprise was completely muzzled by Congress, the consequence of which was
a significant bleeding of the Indian economy.
|
|
Those
who paint false images of enterprise and competition hurt effectively kill
and maim millions of our nameless poor.
|
There
is a global conspiracy to keep India poor. By participating in globalisation
India will become a stooge of multinationals.
|
Openness
and competitiveness of the economy cannot be summarised by misleading
labels such as globalisation.
|
|
There
is never, absolutely never, any justification for slowing down the process
of wealth generation and technical advancement.
|
Our
industry (including our small industry) needs to be sheltered from
competition both internally and externally. (infant industry argument)
|
Sheltered
industry in India became a Frankenstein, devouring Indian consumers but
completely helpless in the face of international competition.
|
|
The
government should never support any form of personal goods or input into
trade, industry for agriculture through any subsidies.
|
The
government should support khadi
|
For
those who are desperately poor, direct transfer of taxes is the only
logical answer.
|
|
Everybody
must get a fair opportunity to display their talent.
|
Everybody
must be equal in what they earn.
|
The
market generally rewards people in proportion to their worth to the rest of
the society
|
|
A
citizen has no “duty” to the nation other than a duty to pay
taxes that are approved through representation, and to obey the laws that
constrain liberties as mutually decided by the citizens through democratic
representation.
|
Article
51A in the Indian Constitution on “Fundamental Duties” was
introduced “to bring our Constitution in line with the constitutions
of China and USSR”. This elevates the nation above the citizen, and
this is absolutely crucial.
|
Our
Constitution is perhaps the world's worst Constitution, since it freezes us
in a point of time and effectively prevents the new generations from
shaping the course of their nation.
|
|
It is
unheard of in democratic society to declare illegal liberal views, for is
these liberal views that give us democracy in the first place.
|
It is
right for our Constitution to declare us to be a socialist country. Only
those political parties who affirm their allegiance to socialism (as
required by S.29 of the Representation of People Act) should be allowed to
contest elections.
|
The
actions of Congress (I) in sabotaging liberalism indicate their strongly
dictatorial tendencies.
|
